Sony refers to Microsoft and Nintendo as minimum in patent applications – and it’s been (at least) over a decade! The question can be somewhat controversial.
A newly issued Sony patent describes Microsoft and Nintendo’s “home entertainment units” as inferior to their own productslike Discover GameRant.
Florian Müller continued his research and dealt with the topic extensively. He discovered and proved through numerous entries that Sony was denigrating Microsoft and Nintendo as “lower quality manufacturers” of video game consoles in numerous patent applications. more than a decade ago.
Dozens of examples are listed Since 2011, proving that this is Sony’s longstanding practice. Again and again, you mention Sony “Other manufacturers, albeit inferior” regarding patent-competing video game consoles.
Florian Mueller reports:
“It is customary and legitimate to explain in patent applications why the claimed invention is superior to the state of the art (i.e. the technology that exists at the time of the patent application). In this context, it is not wrong to discuss some technical drawbacks (such as lower power, higher power consumption, higher memory requirements) Some of the previous inventions.
But calling competitors “inferior” in general is unfounded, stupid, childish, and unprofessional. Even if these manufacturers are inferior, that doesn’t mean that the invention that a particular Sony patent aims to describe—here a “universal console”—is by definition innovative and deserving of patent protection.
Sony is clearly the kind of client many patent attorneys want. If a small company goes to the same patent agents and asks them to file patent specifications that contain such an outrageous passage, most patent attorneys refuse to put their name on it.
“If Sony wants to do comparative advertising, it can do it elsewhere. Players will not base their purchasing decisions on the wording Sony uses in its patent applications.”
[…]
The listing shows that Sony has been doing just that systematically for more than a decade. This has nothing to do with creative pride. It’s just stupid.”
